What is Reusable Holdout?

Overfitting and introducing bias during model training is always a big topic in data science. Typically you train a model using Cross Validation by creating a model on k-1 folds and test it on the remaining one fold. This one fold is the holdout set and will usually work very well if, and only if, the trained model is independent of the holdout set. Under normal situations, this works well, but you might begin to leak information into the model as the test fold changes. The observations in the first test will be different in the second BUT some observations in the first test set will now be in training set. This creates an opportunity to leak’ information into the model.

Ideally, the holdout score gives an accurate estimate of the true performance of the model on the underlying distribution from which the data were drawn. However, this is only the case when the model is independent of the holdout data! In contrast, in a competition the model generally incorporates previously observed feedback from the holdout set. Competitors work adaptively and iteratively with the feedback they receive. An improved score for one submission might convince the team to tweak their current approach, while a lower score might cause them to try out a different strategy. But the moment a team modifies their model based on a previously observed holdout score, they create a dependency between the model and the holdout data that invalidates the assumption of the classic holdout method. As a result, competitors may begin to overfit to the holdout data that supports the leaderboard. This means that their score on the public leaderboard continues to improve, while the true performance of the model does not. In fact, unreliable leaderboards are a widely observed phenomenon in machine learning competitions. (via Moritz Hardt)

What is Reusable Holdout?

Reusable Holdout is a tweak to Cross Validation. It uses the same holdout test set over and over again during training. You select this holdout set prior to Cross Validation and then use it for every iteration of the model building you do, thereby ensuring that nothing potentially leaks into your model building.

Rather than limiting the analyst, our approach provides means of reliably verifying the results of an arbitrary adaptive data analysis. The key tool for doing so is what we call the reusable holdout method. As with the classic holdout method discussed above, the analyst is given unfettered access to the training data. What changes is that there is a new algorithm in charge of evaluating statistics on the holdout set. This algorithm ensures that the holdout set maintains the essential guarantees of fresh data over the course of many estimation steps.

What is Reusable HoldoutWhat is Reusable Holdout

If you want to dig deeper into this topic, check out this research paper here.

Up next H2O World London 2018 - Record Signups! We now return to our regularly scheduled machine learning and sales engineering posts, already in progress… I’m off to London later tonight to go to Humility and Equanimity in Sales Dear Friend, I’ve been meaning to write about the importance humility and equanimity in sales. From my personal past observations, it seems these
Latest posts The Ye Old Blog List Motorola: Then and Now EWM Redux Testing for mean reversion with Python & developing simple VIX system - Talaikis unsorted - Tadas Talaikis Blog Steps to calculate centroids in cluster using K-means clustering algorithm - Data Science Central Basics of Statistical Mean Reversion Testing - QuantStart Algorithmic trading in less than 100 lines of Python code - O’Reilly Media Interpreting Machine Learning Models Microsoft the AI Powerhouse Investing in the S&P500 still beats AI Trading Microsoft makes a push to simplify machine learning | TechCrunch 10 Great Articles On Python Development — Hacker Noon Introduction to Keras Democratising Machine learning with H2O — Towards Data Science Getting started with Python datatable | Kaggle Phone Addiction Version 12 Launches Today! Machine Learning Making Pesto Tastier 5 Dangerous Things You Should Let Your Kids Do The Pyschology of Writing Investing in 2019 and beyond TensorFlow and High Level APIs Driving Marketing Performance with H2O Driverless AI Machine Learning and Data Munging in H2O Driverless AI with datatable Making AI Happen Without Getting Fired Latest Musings from a Traveling Sales Engineer The Night before H2O World 2019 Why Forex Trading is Frustrating Functional Programming in Python Automatic Feature Engineering with Driverless AI Ray Dalio's Pure Alpha Fund